IAG improves capital efficiency and reduces earnings volatility with quota share agreements
The agreements, with reinsurers Munich Re, Swiss Re and Hannover Re, are on a whole-of-account basis, covering IAG’s consolidated business in Australia, New Zealand and Thailand. They have an average initial period of more than five years.
From 1 January 2018, the reinsurers will receive a combined 12.5% of IAG’s consolidated gross earned premium and pay 12.5% of claims and expenses. In addition, IAG will receive an exchange commission which recognises the value of accessing IAG’s strong core franchise. The majority of the exchange commission will be in the form of a fixed fee (as a % of premium) with an additional element in the form of a profit share arrangement which depends on IAG’s future profitability.
The agreements build on the 10-year, 20% whole-of-account quota share arrangement with Berkshire Hathaway which has been in place for over two years, and are expected to deliver similar benefits and financial effects on a pro rata basis:
- Reduced earnings volatility, with 12.5% of insurance risk effectively exchanged for a more stable fee income stream;
- Lower requirement for catastrophe reinsurance and reduced exposure to volatility in associated premium rates;
- A reduction in regulatory capital requirement of approximately $435 million, over a three-year period; and
- Broadly neutral EPS and ROE effects, prior to consideration of potential capital management impacts.
IAG Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer Peter Harmer said the agreements are a logical next step for the company.
“While our strategic priorities of customer, simplification and agility go to the heart of maximising the value of our customer platform, it is important we continue to pursue initiatives that optimise the mix of the supporting capital platform. These transactions are a clear step forward on that front.
“In tandem with the Berkshire Hathaway quota share, we have removed downside earnings risk from 32.5% of our business while retaining significant exposure to earnings upside via the profit share arrangements. We believe this is a good outcome for IAG shareholders,” Mr Harmer said.
IAG Chief Financial Officer Nick Hawkins added: “We have previously indicated our intent to explore further quota share opportunities and are pleased we have been able to meet our return criteria via agreements with three of our key reinsurance counterparties.
“The agreements further reduce the volatility of our earnings, while delivering greater diversity of quota share counterparties and maturities. We see this form of reinsurance capital as an integral part of our capital mix and long-term sustainability,” Mr Hawkins said.
The combined 12.5% quota share agreements will further reduce IAG’s reliance on catastrophe reinsurance cover and its exposure to future volatility in reinsurance rates. In recognition of the new quota share agreements, at its calendar 2018 catastrophe renewal IAG will reduce the placement of its gross cover, from 80% to 67.5%.
IAG’s key capital measure is its Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio, where it employs a benchmark target range of 0.9 to 1.1 times. This compares to a regulatory minimum of 0.6. IAG’s CET1 ratio at 30 June 2017 was 1.09, or 0.93 after allowance for the dividend paid in October 2017.
Based on the mid-point of IAG’s CET1 benchmark, the combined 12.5% quota share agreements are expected to result in an approximately $435 million reduction in IAG’s regulatory capital requirement over a three-year period. The vast majority of this is expected to occur within 18 months, including over $100 million identified at 31 December 2017.
It remains IAG’s intent to maintain its CET1 ratio within its targeted benchmark range, as well as a debt to total tangible capital ratio that supports its existing Standard & Poor’s rating of ‘AA-’ for its core operating subsidiaries.
While the new quota share agreements are expected to result in IAG’s insurance profit being broadly unchanged, they are anticipated to enhance IAG’s reported insurance margin by approximately 250 basis points per annum. This is driven by a lower net earned premium, following the identification of the 12.5% of gross earned premium as a reinsurance expense.
IAG’s FY18 results will include only six months of this effect. Accordingly, IAG has raised its FY18 reported insurance margin guidance by 125 basis points, to 13.75-15.75%.
IAG’s FY18 natural perils allowance reduces to $627 million (from $680 million) to reflect the new quota shares. All other pre-existing guidance assumptions are unchanged.
Aside from the previously mentioned regulatory capital impact on 31 December 2017, the combined 12.5% quota share agreements will have no effect on the 1H18 results for the six months ended 31 December 2017. These will be announced on 14 February 2018.
IAG’s Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer, Peter Harmer, and Chief Financial Officer, Nick Hawkins, provided a briefing on the agreements. An archived recording of the briefing is available here.